The New Electoral Law: How Does it Work?

The Lebanese cupboard has lastly accredited an electoral regulation after months of ongoing debates and disputes. To be sincere, I ended following up on this matter a month or two in the past and I used to be virtually positive they’d undertake the 1960 regulation however one way or the other the cupboard has managed to drag out a brand new regulation that each one events, nicely most of them, agreed on.

The brand new proposed regulation is sort of a sophisticated one and I didn’t have the time or persistence to learn it, however I ran into Jean Nakhoul from MTV on Saturday throughout a birthday dinner, and he was just about explaining to everybody the brand new regulation, so I requested him if he wouldn’t thoughts writing it down in a weblog submit and so he did. I spoke to him for over an hour and he’s so obsessive about elections he had examples of a number of districts with names and variety of votes and all.

Listed below are few issues you might want to know earlier than studying the under:
– Lebanon is now divided into 15 main electoral districts, made up of 27 sub-districts.
– The variety of MPs remains to be 128 and their time period remains to be restricted 4 years.
– Expats will NOT get any seats within the upcoming elections.
– Elections are prone to happen on Could 6 2018, the primary elections in eight years.
– No ladies quota was adopted.
– The brand new regulation will create a proportional illustration system for parliament.
– Voters will get to pick out a full record in addition to select one candidate as their preferential vote.

The districts are divided as follows:
Beirut I (eight seats):
three Armenian Orthodox
1 Armenian Catholic
1 Maronite
1 Catholic
1 Orthodox
1 Minority Christian

Beirut II (11 seats):
6 Sunni
2 Shiite
1 Druze
1 Orthodox
1 Protestant

Baalbeck-Hermel (10 seats):
6 Shiite
2 Sunni
1 Maronite
1 Catholic

Akkar (7 seats):
three Sunni
2 Orthodox
1 Maronite
1 Alawite

Tripoli/Minyeh/Donniyeh (11 seats):
eight Sunni
1 Maronite
1 Orthodox
1 Alawite

Bsharre/Zgharta/Batroun/Koura (10 seats):
7 Maronite
three Orthodox

Jbeil/Kesrouan (eight seats):
7 Maronite
1 Shiite

Nabatieh/Marjayoun/Bint Jbeil/Hasbaya (11 seats):
eight Shiite
1 Sunni
1 Orthodox
1 Druze

West Bekaa/Rashaya (6 seats):
2 Sunni
1 Maronite
1 Orthodox
1 Shiite
1 Druze

Zahle (7 seats):
2 Catholic
1 Armenian Orthodox
1 Maronite
1 Orthodox
1 Shiite
1 Sunni

Aley/Chouf (13 seats):
5 Maronite
four Druze
2 Sunni
1 Orthodox
1 Catholic

Metn (eight seats):
four Maronite
2 Orthodox
1 Catholic
1 Armenian Orthodox

Sidon/Jezzine (5 seats):
2 Maronite
2 Sunni
1 Catholic

Zahrani/Tyre (7 seats):
6 Shiite
1 Catholic

Baabda (6 seats):
three Maronite
2 Shiite
1 Druze

Now yow will discover right here under Jean’s detailed submit, noting that I’m not endorsing any of his opinions or views. The goal is to have a clearer view of the regulation since most individuals don’t really feel like studying 20+ pages. In actual fact I’m all the time skeptical of something our flesh pressers approve of and I extremely suggest you learn Moulahazat’s take on that matter.

New Electoral Legislation Defined – (By Jean Nakhoul)

The electoral regulation isn’t as dangerous as you thought!

Many criticized the brand new electoral regulation agreed upon by the main political events, after 9 years of committees, conferences, research, propositions, and primarily, parliament extensions. Nonetheless, this electoral regulation will not be as dangerous as you will have heard, even if it lacks main reforms like ladies’s quota and continental seats.

The great factors on this regulation are the next:

– The Christians may have the possibility to decide on their representatives in all of the areas. Some stated that the Christian votes will get a most of 49 seats out of 64 however this isn’t true. Even in Baalbeck Hermel the place you have got greater than 100Ok Muslim voters, 15Ok Christian voters can get the maronite seat with the preferential vote.
– No extra place for large blocs. In Metn, 12Ok Armenian voters used to vastly influence the results of the entire record. Now, they’re equal to at least one seat within the proportional regulation, which implies that their votes gained’t have an effect on different seats within the caza. Similar goes with Shiite voters in Jbeil, and Sunni voters in Zahle…
– The proportional system offers each occasion its true consultant parliamentary bloc, and it’ll give the possibility to many individuals whose votes didn’t rely beforehand in massive areas, to solid their votes and make a distinction in each single electoral district.
– Some could say that the system is sectarian. Tremendous, that is the entire regime, and till we alter it or transfer to a civil society, now we have 18 communities to think about within the parliament.
– This regulation will help younger figures and civil actions to be represented within the parliament with a minimal variety of votes. Some stated that that is exhausting for them, however so long as they get the electoral rating (which is the same as the variety of voters divided by the variety of seats) they are going to get a seat. In the event that they don’t, then they merely don’t have sufficient reputation of their district. That is democracy.
– The one factor that might have been higher is utilizing the preferential vote in the entire district not solely the caza. If I can vote to the entire district, why would my preferential vote be solely utilized in my caza? Plus, preferential votes within the district may have helped scale back the sectarian speech, in an effort to have extra voters from totally different sects.

How will the vote rely occur?
Disclaimer: Some names are hypothetical, others are true, however the numbers aren’t consultant of the true electoral state of every. That is solely an instance.

Beirut I:
Complete Voters: 80.000
Complete Seats: eight (three Armenian Orthodox, 1 Armenian Catholic, 1 Maronite, 1 Catholic, 1 Orthodox, 1 Minorite)

PV: Preferential Votes

The variety of seats for every record:

The electoral vote is the same as: 80000 (variety of voters) / eight (variety of seats) = 10000 which implies that each 10000 votes are equal to at least one seat.

Record A will get 37000/10000 = three seats and 7000 votes left
Record B will get 23000/10000 = 2 seats and 3000 votes left
Record C will get 20000/10000 – 2 seats and no votes left

Nonetheless, there may be nonetheless one seat left, it’ll go to Record A who has the most important variety of votes left.

The ultimate result’s:
Record A: four seats
Record B: 2 seats
Record C: 2 seats

Now how to decide on the winners? We take all of the names and the preferential votes they bought and put them so as. In different district the place now we have many caza, now we have to show the preferential votes into percentages as a result of within the North for instance (Becharre – Batroun – Koura – Zghorta) each caza has a unique variety of voters. 2000 in Becharre could be equal to 5000 in Koura.

As you possibly can see, 10 candidates misplaced as a result of the seat of their sect has been taken. This regulation has been tailored to suit the Lebanese sectarian mosaic, and subsequently; the issue will not be with the regulation itself, however relatively with our sectarian regime. With out the sectarian regime, the primary candidates of every record would have gained.

Right here’s one other instance:

Beirut II:

Complete Voters: 150.000
Complete Seats: 11 (6 Sunnis, 2 Chiites, 1 Druze, 1 Orthodox, 1 Protestant)

The variety of seats for every record:
The electoral vote is: 150000 (variety of voters) / 11 (variety of seats) = 13636
Record A will get 80000/13636 = 5 seats and 11820 votes left
Record B will get 36000/10000 = 2 seats and 8728 votes left
Record C will get 34000/10000 = 2 seats and 6728 votes left

2 seats left, one will go to record A, the opposite to record B, since they’ve the best variety of votes left.

The ultimate result’s:
Record A: 6 seats
Record B: three seats
Record C: 2 seats

True, it’s not honest that somebody with 1500 votes wins over somebody with 6000 votes, however once more, blame the sectarian regime, not the electoral regulation. This new regulation gave the possibility to each single occasion to be represented and it’ll absolutely change the political life in Lebanon.

Leave a Reply